Difference between revisions of "Tamas"
Line 10: | Line 10: | ||
}} | }} | ||
<div style='text-align:justify;'> | <div style='text-align:justify;'> | ||
− | Tamas means darkness, illusion, ignorance, inertia, inactivity, dullness etc. It is one of the three fundamental qualities along with sattva and rajas. Tamas has two significant characters i.e. resistance and heaviness. These are responsible for restraining or controlling thoughts. It induces lethargy, fatigue, sleep etc. As per Bhagavad Gita, tamas is responsible for ignorance and sleep. It is the leading cause of darkness in the mind, negligence & delusion, illusion & hallucinations.<ref name="ref1">Mrunalini R. Patel, BSc. Applying the knowledge of ayurveda to appraise the US nutritional paradigm. California College of Ayurveda. 2010 Nov 24.</ref>The excessive lazy and sleepy person has a tamas dominant psychic constitution (Tamasika manas prakriti). [Cha. Sa. ShariraSthana 4/36] This article describes the concept and applications of tamas. | + | Tamas means darkness, illusion, ignorance, inertia, inactivity, dullness etc. It is one of the three fundamental qualities along with [[Sattva|sattva]] and [[Rajas|rajas]]. Tamas has two significant characters i.e. resistance and heaviness. These are responsible for restraining or controlling thoughts. It induces lethargy, fatigue, sleep etc. As per [https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bhagavad_Gita Bhagavad Gita], tamas is responsible for ignorance and sleep. It is the leading cause of darkness in the [[Manas|mind]], negligence & delusion, illusion & hallucinations.<ref name="ref1">Mrunalini R. Patel, BSc. Applying the knowledge of [[Ayurveda|ayurveda]] to appraise the US nutritional paradigm. California College of Ayurveda. 2010 Nov 24.</ref>The excessive lazy and sleepy person has a tamas dominant psychic constitution ([[Tamas|Tamasika]] [[Manas|manas]] [[Prakriti|prakriti]]). [Cha. Sa. ShariraSthana 4/36] This article describes the concept and applications of tamas. |
</div> | </div> | ||
{{Infobox | {{Infobox | ||
Line 40: | Line 40: | ||
=== Classical interpretations === | === Classical interpretations === | ||
<div style='text-align:justify;'> | <div style='text-align:justify;'> | ||
− | Sattva, rajas, and tamas are connected with three doshas (Vata, pitta, kapha) [Su. Sa. ShariraSthana 4/23] | + | [[Sattva|Sattva]], [[Rajas|rajas]], and tamas are connected with three [[Dosha|doshas]] ([[Vata dosha|Vata]], [[Pitta dosha|pitta]], [[Kapha|kapha]]) [Su. Sa. ShariraSthana 4/23] |
Therefore, all neurophysiological functions of the body are coordinated by them. | Therefore, all neurophysiological functions of the body are coordinated by them. | ||
− | Tamas has been described in the context of three types of mental strengths (trividha sattva), psychological constitutions (prakriti), & psychological characteristics (manasaguna). [Cha. Sa. ShariraSthana 4/36] | + | Tamas has been described in the context of three types of mental strengths (trividha sattva), psychological constitutions ([[Prakriti|prakriti]]), & psychological characteristics (manasaguna). [Cha. Sa. ShariraSthana 4/36] |
* It is mentioned in the context of three fundamental universal qualities (mahaguna) [As Sa, sutra sthana 1/41]. | * It is mentioned in the context of three fundamental universal qualities (mahaguna) [As Sa, sutra sthana 1/41]. | ||
* Tama is described under mahaprakriti [Su. Sa. ShariraSthana 4/97] & twelve pranas. [Su. Sa. ShariraSthana 4/3] | * Tama is described under mahaprakriti [Su. Sa. ShariraSthana 4/97] & twelve pranas. [Su. Sa. ShariraSthana 4/3] | ||
Line 48: | Line 48: | ||
</div> | </div> | ||
− | '''Properties of tamas:''' Pungent (katu) & astringent (kashaya) [As. Sa. Sutra Sthana 12/91] | + | '''Properties of tamas:''' [[Katu|Pungent (katu)]] & [[Kashaya|astringent (kashaya)]] [As. Sa. Sutra Sthana 12/91] |
− | a]. It increases the desire for pleasure (kamavardhaka), reduces fatigue in the body and mind (klamahara), responsible for darkness. It leads to confusion (mohajanak), hallucination (drikabhramaka), heaviness (guru), and forgetfulness (avaraka). [Bhava | + | a]. It increases the desire for pleasure (kamavardhaka), reduces fatigue in the [[Sharira|body]] and [[Manas|mind]] (klamahara), responsible for darkness. It leads to confusion (mohajanak), hallucination (drikabhramaka), heaviness (guru), and forgetfulness (avaraka). [Bhava Prakash Nighantu 1: 4: 273] |
=== Characteristics of tamasika person === | === Characteristics of tamasika person === | ||
− | Overthinker or depressed (vishada), atheist (naastika), does not follow proper rules & regulations (adharmasheela), lethargy (akarmasheela), fond of excessive sleep (nidaralu), senseless | + | Overthinker or depressed (vishada), atheist (naastika), does not follow proper rules & regulations (adharmasheela), lethargy (akarmasheela), fond of excessive [[Nidra|sleep (nidaralu)]], senseless (durmedhastvam). [Su. Sa. ShariraSthana 1/18] |
</div> | </div> | ||
Line 58: | Line 58: | ||
<div style='text-align:justify;'> | <div style='text-align:justify;'> | ||
During the evolutionary process, the five basic elements are created by the combination of triguna.12) [Su Sa ShariraSthana 1/3-4] | During the evolutionary process, the five basic elements are created by the combination of triguna.12) [Su Sa ShariraSthana 1/3-4] | ||
− | The earth element (prithvimahabhuta) is created by tamas. [SuSa. ShariraSthana 1/20]. Sattva entity is cause for reflection of a person's purity, essence, and intelligence. Rajas is responsible for all the movements of body or mind. Tamas is responsible for the equilibrium of the quality of sattva and rajas. <ref name="ref3">Satva, rajas, tamas as per ayurveda by Raghuram Y.S (Md ayu), Dr Manasa (bams) available on //www.easyayurveda.com/2019/01/15/tridosha-satva-rajas-tamas</ref> | + | The [[Prithvi mahabhuta|earth element (prithvimahabhuta)]] is created by tamas. [SuSa. ShariraSthana 1/20]. [[Sattva|Sattva]] entity is cause for reflection of a person's purity, essence, and intelligence. [[Rajas|Rajas]] is responsible for all the movements of [[Sharira|body]] or [[Manas|mind]]. Tamas is responsible for the equilibrium of the quality of [[Sattva|sattva]] and [[Rajas|rajas]]. <ref name="ref3">Satva, rajas, tamas as per ayurveda by Raghuram Y.S (Md ayu), Dr Manasa (bams) available on //www.easyayurveda.com/2019/01/15/tridosha-satva-rajas-tamas</ref> |
− | Kapha dosha is made up of water (jala), earth (prithvi).[As. sa. Sutra Stana20/3] Kapha dosha maintains the equilibrium of vata and pitta dosha and also reduces adverse effects of vata& pitta dosha. Rajas is connected with vata dosha, sattva with pitta dosha, and tamas with kapha dosha as per similarity in creation and functions.<ref name="ref3" /> he diet and regimen that increases physical entities also enhance psychological entities. | + | [[Kapha|Kapha dosha]] is made up of [[Jala mahabhuta|water (jala)]], [[Prithvi mahabhuta|earth (prithvi)]].[As. sa. Sutra Stana20/3] [[Kapha|Kapha dosha]] maintains the equilibrium of [[Vata dosha|vata]] and [[Pitta dosha|pitta dosha]] and also reduces adverse effects of [[Vata dosha|vata]] & [[Pitta dosha|pitta dosha]]. Rajas is connected with [[Vata dosha|vata dosha]], sattva with [[Pitta dosha|pitta dosha]], and tamas with [[Kapha|kapha dosha]] as per similarity in creation and functions.<ref name="ref3" /> he diet and regimen that increases physical entities also enhance psychological entities. |
</div> | </div> | ||
== Diet and regimen that increases the quality of tamas == | == Diet and regimen that increases the quality of tamas == | ||
− | <div style='text-align:justify;'>The food that makes the mind sluggish and promotes diseases increases tamas. | + | <div style='text-align:justify;'>The food that makes the mind sluggish and promotes [[Vyadhi|diseases]] increases tamas. |
− | As per Bhagavad Gita, tamasika food requires a lot of energy and time to digest. It has a grounding effect, usually creating passivity and reducing body and mind activity. Characters of the food liked by tamasika person are as follow: | + | As per Bhagavad Gita, tamasika food requires a lot of energy and time to digest. It has a grounding effect, usually creating passivity and reducing [[Sharira|body]] and [[Manas|mind]] activity. Characters of the food liked by tamasika person are as follow: |
<ol><li style="font-weight:bold">Yatayamam: <span style="font-weight:normal">The food which has passed a three and half hours time (one yama) after its preparation.</span></li> | <ol><li style="font-weight:bold">Yatayamam: <span style="font-weight:normal">The food which has passed a three and half hours time (one yama) after its preparation.</span></li> | ||
<li style="font-weight:bold">Gatarasa (tasteless): <span style="font-weight:normal">The food which has lost its original taste and quality because of over or under-cooking, without adding all ingredients that are required for preparation.</span></li> | <li style="font-weight:bold">Gatarasa (tasteless): <span style="font-weight:normal">The food which has lost its original taste and quality because of over or under-cooking, without adding all ingredients that are required for preparation.</span></li> |
Revision as of 11:00, 25 November 2022
Tamas means darkness, illusion, ignorance, inertia, inactivity, dullness etc. It is one of the three fundamental qualities along with sattva and rajas. Tamas has two significant characters i.e. resistance and heaviness. These are responsible for restraining or controlling thoughts. It induces lethargy, fatigue, sleep etc. As per Bhagavad Gita, tamas is responsible for ignorance and sleep. It is the leading cause of darkness in the mind, negligence & delusion, illusion & hallucinations.[1]The excessive lazy and sleepy person has a tamas dominant psychic constitution (Tamasika manas prakriti). [Cha. Sa. ShariraSthana 4/36] This article describes the concept and applications of tamas.
Section/Chapter/topic | Concepts/Tamas |
---|---|
Authors |
Bhojani M. K. 1, Kabadwal Dipti2 |
Reviewer | Basisht G.2, |
Editor | Deole Y.S.3 |
Affiliations |
1 Department of Sharir Kriya, All India Institute of Ayurveda, New Delhi, India 2Department of Samhita Siddhant, A.I.I.A., New Delhi, India 3 Rheumatologist, Orlando, Florida, U.S.A. 4Department ofKayachikitsa, G.J.Patel Institute of Ayurvedic Studies and Research, New Vallabh Vidyanagar, Gujarat, India |
Correspondence emails |
meera.samhita@aiia.gov.in, carakasamhita@gmail.com |
Publisher | Charak Samhita Research, Training and Development Centre, I.T.R.A., Jamnagar, India |
Date of publication: | November 21, 2022 |
DOI | In process |
Etymology and derivation
Tamas is the Sanskrit word that means darkness, inert, dullness or inactivity.[2] It is derived from the word ‘tama’ meaning darkness.
Classical interpretations
Sattva, rajas, and tamas are connected with three doshas (Vata, pitta, kapha) [Su. Sa. ShariraSthana 4/23] Therefore, all neurophysiological functions of the body are coordinated by them. Tamas has been described in the context of three types of mental strengths (trividha sattva), psychological constitutions (prakriti), & psychological characteristics (manasaguna). [Cha. Sa. ShariraSthana 4/36]
- It is mentioned in the context of three fundamental universal qualities (mahaguna) [As Sa, sutra sthana 1/41].
- Tama is described under mahaprakriti [Su. Sa. ShariraSthana 4/97] & twelve pranas. [Su. Sa. ShariraSthana 4/3]
- Tamas is described as karanadravya. (Acharya Prabhakara)
Properties of tamas: Pungent (katu) & astringent (kashaya) [As. Sa. Sutra Sthana 12/91] a]. It increases the desire for pleasure (kamavardhaka), reduces fatigue in the body and mind (klamahara), responsible for darkness. It leads to confusion (mohajanak), hallucination (drikabhramaka), heaviness (guru), and forgetfulness (avaraka). [Bhava Prakash Nighantu 1: 4: 273]
Characteristics of tamasika person
Overthinker or depressed (vishada), atheist (naastika), does not follow proper rules & regulations (adharmasheela), lethargy (akarmasheela), fond of excessive sleep (nidaralu), senseless (durmedhastvam). [Su. Sa. ShariraSthana 1/18]
Interrelationship of tamas with five basic elements (panchamahubhuta) and dosha
During the evolutionary process, the five basic elements are created by the combination of triguna.12) [Su Sa ShariraSthana 1/3-4] The earth element (prithvimahabhuta) is created by tamas. [SuSa. ShariraSthana 1/20]. Sattva entity is cause for reflection of a person's purity, essence, and intelligence. Rajas is responsible for all the movements of body or mind. Tamas is responsible for the equilibrium of the quality of sattva and rajas. [3] Kapha dosha is made up of water (jala), earth (prithvi).[As. sa. Sutra Stana20/3] Kapha dosha maintains the equilibrium of vata and pitta dosha and also reduces adverse effects of vata & pitta dosha. Rajas is connected with vata dosha, sattva with pitta dosha, and tamas with kapha dosha as per similarity in creation and functions.[3] he diet and regimen that increases physical entities also enhance psychological entities.
Diet and regimen that increases the quality of tamas
As per Bhagavad Gita, tamasika food requires a lot of energy and time to digest. It has a grounding effect, usually creating passivity and reducing body and mind activity. Characters of the food liked by tamasika person are as follow:
- Yatayamam: The food which has passed a three and half hours time (one yama) after its preparation.
- Gatarasa (tasteless): The food which has lost its original taste and quality because of over or under-cooking, without adding all ingredients that are required for preparation.
- Pooti (putrid): Food that has a putrid odor. Ex. garlic, onion, mushroom, frozen etc.
- Parushita (stale food): Packed bread, bottled or canned food, preserved food etc.
- Amedhya: Food that reduces intelligence, concentration, and coordination of body & mind. It deprives mental health. Junk foods like cakes, biscuits, chocolate, sweets, sugary drink, energy & soft drink, snacks such as chips, excessive alcohol, processed meat etc.
Effect of tamas on body & mind
Classification
- Pashava (animal trait): The person who can’t deal with the trickysituation (nirakarishnum), is senseless (amedhyam), has less amount of food & exercise (jugupsitacharahara), has pleasure towards excess coitus (maithunam) & excess sleepy (param swapnsheelam) shows pashava trait in tamas constitution.
- Maatsya (fish trait): Coward (bheeru), unintellectual (abudham), fond of food (aaharlubdha), frail body & mind (anavasthita), always having anger & desires (anushakatakamakrodham), mobile (saranasheelam), likes water (toyakaamam) are characteristic features of fish trait in tamas constitution.
- Vanaspatya (tree trait): Excessive laziness (aalasyam), always fond of food (kevalambhininivishtamaahare), void of external and internal wisdom (sarvabudhyangaheenam), who does not follow rules and regulations, lack of wealth and dignity (sattvadharmarthakamavarjitam) are characteristic features of tree trait in tamas constitution. [Cha. Sa. shariraSthana 4/39]
Applied aspect
Tamas is involved as an essential pathogenic factor in some diseases given below.
- Intoxication, psychoneurosis (mada)
- Unconsciousness (murccha)
- Extreme alcoholism (madatayaya)
- Coma (sanyasa)
- Insanity (unmada)
- Epilepsy (apasmara)
- Intellectual defects (prajnaparadha)
- Hallucination, delusion, obsession, illusion (attatvabhinivesha)
- Lust (kama)
- Confusion (moha)
- Grief (shoka)
- Depression (vishada)
- Drowsiness (tandra)[4]
- Delusion: It is a false belief based on incorrect inferences. This symptom is usually seen in schizophrenia.
- Hallucinations: It isa false perception by special senses without any external stimulus. Hallucination may be seen in insanity, high-grade fever, & in drug poisoning.
- Illusion: It is the false perception by the special senses of external stimuli.
- Impulse: A sudden desire to do something without external stimuli or thinking about the result. usually this character is seen in dementia, epilepsy etc
- Obsession: Excessive thoughts, ideas, or emotions that cannot be eliminated logically
- Lucid internal: It is the period at which all signs and symptoms of insanity are not visible, and the person's behavior looks healthy.[5]
General principles of treatment
Maintaining nutritional status, prevention & cure of mental illness needs proper living conditions & environment that promotes mental health. Following are principles for the prevention and treatment of pacifying tamas relating disorders.
- Intake of a balanced diet
- Following rules and regulations for the preparation & intake of food (ashthaaharavidhivisheshayatana) and dietary guidelines (aharavidhi)
- Daily regimen (dinacharya)
- Night regimen (ratricharya)
- Seasonal regimen (ritucharya)
Specific treatments of tamas dominant disorders
- Restraining psychological urges (manasikavega dharana): Psychological urges like greed (lobha), grief (shoka), fear (bhaya), jealousy (irshya), dislike (dwesha), infatuation (raga), arrogance (ahankara), shameless (nirlajja) etc. shall be controlled. [Cha. Sa. Sutra Sharira 7/25-29]
- Spiritual therapy (daivavyapashrayachikitsa): It includes chanting & listening to mantras, homa , fasting (upavasa), aushadhi, wearing of mani, auspicious ceremony (mangala), gifts (upahara) following of auspicious & spiritual rules (niyama), respect of almighty (pranipata) are an integral part of daivayapashrayachikitsa. This leads to activating the normal functioning of sattva and removes excessive tamas & rajas.[6]
- Rational therapy (yuktivyapashrayachikitsa): Aimed at rational use of medicines (internal & external or both) and food (Ahara). Which are further classified into two types:[7]
- Shamana: This normalizes the dosha in the body. Some medicines indicated in mental illness are described below:
- Purification procedures (shodhana) : Elimination of excessively aggravated dosha leads to equilibrium in body. Panchakarma treatment like vamana,virechana, nasya, niruha, anuvasana are described in mental illness. [Ch. Sa. ChikitsaSthana 10/61]
- Psychotherapy (sattvajaya): Psychotherapy aims at regulating the mind. Assurance, diversion of emotions, control of thought process, proper guidance, proper regulation of patience, shock therapy etc. are applied for the regulation of tamas. ) [Cha. Sa. Sutra Sthana 11/54]
- Naisthikichikitsa : Elimination of desires, and ambitions (upadha), which are the prime causes of mental illness is an important measure. Eliminating cravings leads to eradicating all diseases associated with the mind, especially tamas.[4]
- Yoga: By the practice of ashtanga yoga (yama, niyama, asana, prayanama, pratyahara, dharana, dhyana and samadhi), one can attain the state of salvation (moksha). This increases sattva and decreases rajas & tamas.[4]
Single drugs | Centella asiatica Linn. (Mandukaparni), Convolvulaspleuricaulis (Shankhapushpi), Tinospora cordifolia Miers. (Guduchi), Glycyrrhiza glabra Linn. (Madhuyashthi) 24) [Cha. Sa. ChikitsaSthana 1/30-31] |
---|---|
Ghee | Kalyanakaghrita, mahakalyanakghritapanchagavyaghrita, purana ghrita, prapuranaghrita [Cha. Sa. ChikitsaSthana 9/35-61]
Mahapaishachikaghrita, Brahmi ghrita, Lashunadighrita, Shatadhautaghrita,) [Cha. Sa. ChikitsaSthana 10/17-25] etc. |
Syrup | Shankhapushpi[8] |
Oil | Shadapidutailam [Bhaisajyaratnavali, Shirorogadhikara 65/81-83] |
Rasa aushadhi | Smritisagara rasa, [YogaratnakarApasamaraChikitsa] Unmadagajankusha rasa[3][BhaishajyaratnavaliUnmadaRogadhikara] |
Current researches
- Tri-gunas (Sattva, rajas and tamas) and risk-taking behavior among undergraduate students: A study was conducted to evaluate the relation between tri-gunas factors in personality and risk- taking behavior among undergraduate students. Total 192 under graduate students (94 male & 98 female) were selected by adopting random sampling method. The tools used for the study were personality assessment. The conclusion of this study is that there is no significant co-relation between personalities (mental constitution) and risk taking behaviour.[9]
- Transformational Leadership &Triguna Theory: The research suggests techniques aimed on inward growth of self-management. Techniques suggested for the promotion of sattva could be applied for the development of transformation leadership. Concept of triguna provides a useful system to understand leadership. The type of attribute dominant in the leader at a particular set of time is responsible for the way he reacts to the challenges at work. Therefore, no similarities between the two concepts exist, these two theories need not be compartmentalized as Indian and Western approaches to individual development.[10]
- DEMOGRAPHIC CORRELATES OF TRIGUNA (2013)[11]: The study was performed to evaluate relationship of triguna with eight demographic variables namely management level, type of organization, years in service, mode of recruitment, age, level of education, wife's working position and family structure. Two hundred managers of level II and level III from service and manufacturing sector organization in Lucknow were administered the Vedic Personality Inventory and the questionnaire for biographical information. On an average, the managers had to devote 20 minutes to fill the questionnaire. Conclusion of the study depict that joint and nuclear families provide different social environment. The obtained results show that managers from joint families are higher on sattva guna than managers from nuclear families. The managers from nuclear families are higher on tamas guna than managers from joint families. Another important point observed in the results was that rajas and tamas both were dominant in managers. Since not much research is done in this area, this trend needs further probing in the form of researches on triguna as theoretically rajas and tamas are very opposite to each other.
Research theses
- Srivatsa (2000): Concept of Manasa Prakriti and its role in Psychopathology w.s.r to AnavastitaCittatva (General Anxiety Disorders) and its Management. Department of Basic Principles IPGT&RA, Jamnagar :
This research showed that manasaprakrti plays main role in vulnerability (hetuskandha), severity, prognosis (lingaskandha), bioavailability of drugs, dose, mode of administration, route of administration (chikitsaskandha). Anavasthitachittatva (unstable mind), a vatananatmajavikara can be considered as minor psychic disorders. There is reduced quality of tamas, and excess sattva and rajas. Tamas cause sleep and calmness, while rajas is responsible for alertness, activity etc. - Kavita M. Vyas (2011): Interrelationship of Shareera-Doshas and Manasa-Doshas and their influence on physiopsychopathology. Department of Basic Principles,IPGT&RA, Jamnagar :
In this study, interrelationship between both kinds of doshas has been established at different levels like origin, functioning, health, diseases and salvation was sudied. Conjugation & configuration (amshamsha Kalpana) of mahabhuta was applied. On the basis of clinical observations and results, it was concluded that sharira dosha, kapha and vata have affinity with manasa attributes sattva and rajas, respectively. When vata gets provoked due to obstruction, it shows resemblance with tamas. Though qualities of vata& tamas are quite opposite, the functions of tamas is observed to be similar to that of vata. This appear mainly due to kshaya of vata instead of vruddhi of tamas. The logic behind such interrelationship is that the activities carried out due to the qualities of tamas are inversely proportionate to functions of vata. This concept supports the theory of disease production due to decline of dosha, which actually causes comparative increase of the opposite dosha. The second reason behind the phenomenon mentioned above is avarana of vata as 'avaranam’ is the function of tamas. Sattvavajaya is a group of remedies that are targeted to conquest mind. The clinical study was oriented to support the classical as well as practical relationship of both kinds of dosha. - Dr Hetal D. Amin (2012): Philosophical and applied ayurvedic aspects of manas with special reference to smriti. Department of Basic Principles IPGT&RA, Jamnagar.
Mental factors (manas hetu) play an important role keeping healthy status as well as disease production. Vitiation of rajas and tamas causes many diseases. Tamas causes obstruction of vata dosha leading to psychosomatic disorders. As sattvavajayachikitsa stands first in the management of mental disorders (manas vyadhi), hence it is better to adopt sattvavajayachikitsa for managing mental diseases.
References
- ↑ 1.0 1.1 Mrunalini R. Patel, BSc. Applying the knowledge of ayurveda to appraise the US nutritional paradigm. California College of Ayurveda. 2010 Nov 24.
- ↑ https://en.m.wikipedia.org
- ↑ 3.0 3.1 3.2 Satva, rajas, tamas as per ayurveda by Raghuram Y.S (Md ayu), Dr Manasa (bams) available on //www.easyayurveda.com/2019/01/15/tridosha-satva-rajas-tamas
- ↑ 4.0 4.1 4.2 Kumar Jitendra1, Gond Pushpa, Byadgi P.S.31Junior Resident. Critical evaluation of manas roga in ayurveda. Indian Journal of Agriculture and Allied Sciences. 2015 Jun 27;106-107. ISSN 2395-1109 Volume: 1, No.: 2.
- ↑ Gautam Biswas,Review of forensic medicine and toxicology , 2nd edition chapter 29 page number 353-35. Jaypee brothers medical publishers (p) limited.
- ↑ Sudha IshwarlalLokhande, Sudarshan Hande. Manasatattava and its chikitsasiddhanta, explained in Ayurveda.
- ↑ https://www.planetayurveda.com/manas-chikitsa-in-ayurveda/
- ↑ www.ayurtimes.com/shankhpushpi-syrup-benefits-side-effects/
- ↑ Jain, Dr. Rajat. _trigunas sattva rajas and tamas and risk taking behaviour among understanding students (2016). International Journal of Research Granthaalayah. 10.13140/RG.2.1.2825.1928.
- ↑ Dhulla, Tejal. Transformational leadership &triguna theory: a short literature review. International Journal of Advanced Research.2014 2. 314-356.
- ↑ Kewalramani, Soni& Mukta, Prof & Rastogi, Rani. Demographic correlations of trigunas. Journal of Advanced Research, Vol. 1, Issue 9, September, 2013. 1. 33-47.